Near-Infrared Spectroscopy Correlates with Established Histological Scores in a Miniature Pig Model of Cartilage Regeneration
Daniel Guenther 1, Chaoxu Liu 1, Hauke Horstmann 1, Christian Krettek 1, Michael Jagodzinski 1, Carl Haasper*, 1, 2
Identifiers and Pagination:Year: 2014
First Page: 93
Last Page: 99
Publisher ID: TOORTHJ-8-93
Article History:Received Date: 29/1/2014
Revision Received Date: 10/4/2014
Acceptance Date: 22/4/2014
Electronic publication date: 16/5/2014
Collection year: 2014
open-access license: This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/) which permits unrestrictive use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (NIRS) could be of clinical relevance in modern cartilage regeneration.In a miniature pig model correlation of measurements and histologic scores have never been used before. The data analysis was part of an animal project that investigated the effects of seeding a chondrogenic and osteogenic scaffold with a bone-marrow-derived cell concentrate and reports the histological and mechanical properties. We created 20 osteochondral defects in the femoral condyles of 10 miniature pigs.The defects were left empty (E), filled with the grafted cylinder upside down (U), or with a combined scaffold (S) containing a spongy bone cylinder covered with a collagen membrane. In the fourth group, the same scaffolds were implanted but seeded with a stem cell concentrate (S+BMCC). The animals were euthanized after 3 months, and histologic and spectrometric analyses were performed. NIRS measurements were significantly higher in the central area of the defects of group S+BMCC compared to the central area of the defects of group U. In all groups, a correlation between NIRS and the histologic scores could be demonstrated though on different levels. In the central area, a good NIRS measurement correlates with low (good) histologic scores. In group E and group S, this negative correlation was significant (p=0.01). For the first time, NIRS was successfully used to evaluate osteochondral constructs in a miniature pig model.
Osteochondral defects are common in orthopedic and trauma surgery.  Various orthopedic procedures for osteochondral reconstruction have been developed  including autologous chondrocyte transplantation, osteochondral grafts [3, 4], and modern methods of regenerative medicine. Several diagnostic tools to examine the properties of reconstructions exist. Some of them require invasive procedures. NIRS has been introduced as a less invasive method for determining tissue properties in various cases. Multiple studies have shown the potential to evaluate tissues of brain [5-7], heart , and skin . In recent years, NIRS has become established in the measurement of the properties of articular cartilage . The main disadvantage of NIRS is an overlapping of the individual bands. Molecules absorb little in the visible region. In the NIR region, however, almost all molecules absorb, in particular organic compounds with CH-, NH-, OH-groups. Moreover, water as a main component of most organic samples, has a very broad and relatively blurred absorption peak. It is a strong NIR absorber. Using computer analysis, however, it is usually possible to compare NIR spectra with corresponding references (NIR libraries). In this way a molecular finger print is generated . Osteoarthritis leads to changes in biochemical, biophysical and histological properties of thearticular cartilage . This leeds to a break up of the collagen-glucosamine matrix and changes in water-binding properties and a shift in the ratio of the main cartilage components, water and collagen II . The mechanical resistance and the biophysical characteristics of cartilage against load are changed . Infra- red light interacts with these cartilage components, which are affected by Osteoarthritis, such as water, water-binding properties, CH-, OH- and SH-groups. Studies have shown, that Osteoarthritis can be detectable with this method .
It was shown that the biomechanical characteristics of cartilage could be calculated from the corresponding NIRS spectra . The correlation with histologic scores, like Wakitani and Pineda, has to be demonstrated. Histologic and mechanical examination protocols for the evaluation of osteochondral reconstructions have been well described in the literature . The Pineda and Wakitani scores are widely used in histopathology. NIRS has been used in a rat model so far. To the authors' knowledge, it has not been used to evaluate osteochondral lesions in a miniature pig model. The aims of this study were to establish the NIRS method in a miniature pig model of modern cartilage regeneration and to evaluate the correlation of the measurements with histologic scores like Pineda and Wakitani.
MATERIALS AND METHODOLOGY
The NIRS data analysis was a part of an animal project that investigated the effects of seeding a chondrogenic and osteogenic scaffold with a bone-marrow-derived cell concentrate and reports the histological and mechanical properties 3 months after implantation in a miniature pig . We created 20 osteochondral defects, 7 mm in diameter and 10 mm in height, in the femoral condyles of 10 miniature pigs. Autologous Cells from the iliac crest were concentrated using a concentration system (Marrowstim®, Biomed, Warsaw, Indiana). 20 ml of bone marrow aspirate were used to create 3 ml of concentrate. The concentrate was transferred in a custom made cell seeding device (manufactured by the Institutional Central Research Laboratories of Hannover Medical School (MHH) as previously described . In one group the combined scaffold (S) containing a spongy bone cylinder (Tutobone®) covered with a collagen membrane (Chondrogide®) was seeded with the stem cell concentrate (S+BMCC). In the other groups, the defects were left empty (E), filled with the grafted cylinder upside down (U), or with the combined unseeded scaffold (S). The group size was n=5. The animals were euthanized after 3 months, and mechanical, macroscopic , histologic, and spectrometric analyses were performed. This publication reports the correlation of histologic and spectrometric results. Table 1 shows the allocation of pigs and condyles to each of the 4 groups. Table 2 shows the study design.
Allocation of pigs and condyles to each of the 4 groups.
|Unilateral: Right Knee Joint|
Histological evaluation of the specimen was carried out as previously described. The modified Wakitani Score (Table 3)  and the modified Pineda Score (Table 4)  were used for evaluation of the regenerate - native cartilage interface.
Modified Wakitani score .
|Mostly hyaline cartilage||1|
|Matrix staining (metachromasia) (Toludine blue-stained slides)|
|Normal (compared to host)||0|
|No metachromatic stain||3|
|Surface regularity (Total smooth area of reparative cartilage compared to the whole area of the cartilage defect)|
|Severely irregular (1/4)||3|
|Thickness of cartilage (Average thickness of reparative cartilage compared to that of surrounding cartilage)|
|Integration of repair tissue to surrounding articular cartilage|
|Both edges integrated||0|
|One edge integrated||1|
|Both edges not integrated||2|
Modified Pineda score .
|Filling of the Defect||Score|
|Reconstruction of the Osteochondral Junction||Score|
|Most hyaline and fibrocartilage||1|
|Some fibrocartilage, but non-chondrocytic cells||3|
|Non-chondrocytic cells only||4|
NIRS was performed using a probe connected with a personal computer as described previously . The measures were performed directly on the cartilage surface after sacrificing the animals. The probe (Arthrospec, Jena, Germany) was deserved to be of similar shape and size to an arthroscopic probe with a central tip of 1 mm. In order to measure the diffuse reflexion of cartilage, six optical fibers were integrated with a diameter of 200 μm each. For spectral analysis, we used a fiber-coupled diode array micro-spectrometer (MCS Zeiss Micro imaging) with a spectral range of 900 to 1700 nm and an optical resolution of 10 nm. A total of 50 light pulses were applied and the modified NIRS absorption was evaluated. Within 1 s measuring time an arthroscopy print with a value that lies between 0 and 100 appeared. This semi-quantitative value was the result of experimental studies [14, 16]. The changes in the NIRS absorption correlate with the biomechanical properties (Shore hardness, Young's modulus) as well as biochemical changes (water influx and thus relative decrease of the anhydrous matrix content) and the histological changes. They reflect an integral snap-reading method of the degree of degeneration of the cartilage within the measured areas .
Three measurements were made in the center and in the periphery of the defects and the mean values were used for further analysis. As a control, we used healthy cartilage.
If the measured values are between 0 and 40, it is an indication for the presence of heavy degenerative damaged cartilage tissue. Values between 40 and 70 are an indication for moderate damage. Values between 70 and 100 are a predictor of little or no degeneration in the cartilage matrix .
The results were compared to the modified histologic Wakitani score and the histologic Pineda score and tested for correlation.
Data were processed with the statistical software package SPSS (version 20.0, SPSS Inc., Chicago, USA). Data are reported using mean values and standard deviation. Interference statistical analyses were performed for two independent samples using the Mann-Whitney U Test. The Kruskal-Wallis Test was used to check several independent samples. Spearman’s rank correlation was used to characterize links between parameters. Diagrams were created with the software package Excel (version 14.2.4, Microsoft®, Redmond, USA).
The surgical procedures were approved by the local district veterinary administration and complied with the animal protection act. The study was conducted in accordance with the standards set forth in the eighth edition of Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals published by the National Academy of Sciences, The National Academies Press, Washington, DC.
The Wakitani Score  and the Pineda Score  were used for evaluation of the regenerate - native cartilage interface. Fig. (1) shows an example of a histological section of each group stained light green.
Histological evaluation of the different groups (n=5) using the Pineda score (*p < 0.05).
Histological evaluation of the different groups (n=5) using the Wakitani score (*p < 0.05).
Further histological evaluations are part of another publication . We previously demonstrated in this animal model that stem cell concentrates enhance new bone formation but fail to improve mechanical properties or histological appearance of regenerated cartilage in critical size defects. Fig. (4) demonstrates the NIRS measurements of the regenerated cartilage for the four groups.
NIRS measurements of the regenerated cartilage for the four groups (n=5) (*p < 0.05).
Measurements were significantly higher in the central area of the defects of group S+BMCC compared to the center of the defects of group U. Furthermore, no significant differences between the four groups could be achieved. Table 5 shows the correlation between the Wakitani Score, the Pineda Score, and the peripheral as well as central NIRS measurements in the total of all groups.
Correlation between the Wakitani score, the Pineda score, and the peripheral and central NIRS measurements in the total of all groups.
|NIRS Central||NIRS Peripheral||Wakitani||Pineda|
In all groups, a correlation between NIRS and the histologic scores could be demonstrated though on different levels. In the central areas, a good NIRS measurement correlated with low (good) histologic scores. In group E and group S, this negative correlation was significant. In the central area of the defects in group U, no negative correlation could be demonstrated. However, the NIRS values and the histologic scores did not correlate which clearly in the peripheral areas.
Near-infrared spectroscopy is progressively establishing itself as a modern method in the assessment of defects on the articular surface. It may be particularly helpful in the evaluation of the benefit of different medical or surgical interventions in the early stages of articular cartilage damage . It was demonstrated that the thickness of articular cartilage can be measured spectroscopically using NIR light . NIRS could distinguish between normal and degraded tissue  and between different stages of osteoarthritic progression . In arthroscopic procedures, near-infrared spectroscopy has a better inter-observer correlation than grading by ICRS score . It offers the ability to monitor macromolecular content of cartilage constructs to assess engineered cartilage in situ . NIRS correlates significantly with the Mankin score in an osteoarthritic rat model , but it has never before been established in an osteoarthritic mini-pig model to evaluate osteochondral regenerates. Furthermore, the correlation with histologic scores like Wakitani and Pineda had to be demonstrated. Studies have already shown that NIRS correlates with the ICRS-2 histological score . The ICRS score of this animal project is part of another publication. To the authors’ knowledge, the reisno study, that deals with the correlation of NIRS and Wakitani and Pineda scores. The ICRS score contains a surface zone score. The Wakitani score contains this as well. In the Pineda score the surface zone is not included. The penetration depth of NIR light is strongly dependant on the wave length used. The surface is always measured. That might be a reason, why the Wakitani score seems to be slightly more correlative to NIRS than the Pineda score.
Table 6 presents the correlation between the various parameters for the respective groups.
Correlation between the Wakitani score, the Pineda score, and the peripheral and central NIRS measurements for the respective groups.
|Group E||NIRS Central||NIRS Peripheral||Wakitani||Pineda|
|Group U||NIRS Central||NIRS Peripheral||Wakitani||Pineda|
|Group S||NIRS Central||NIRS Peripheral||Wakitani||Pineda|
|Group S+BMCC||NIRS Central||NIRS Peripheral||Wakitani||Pineda|
Another reason could possibly be the higher amount of sub-divisions in the Wakitani score, thus the score might be more accurate . Studies have demonstrated that NIRS is a feasible tool to distinguish between normal and degraded tissue in osteoarthritis and traumatic lesions [24, 27]. The data of the NIRS measurements in group E can confirm this evidence. It could also be demonstrated that NIRS is useful to evaluate bony tissue reconstruction using scaffolds  as in group S. NIRS is not yet well established for cell-loaded constructs like we used in group S+BMCC. Further studies are required to evaluate spectroscopy in the tissue engineering of cartilage lesions. NIRS values and the histologic scores do not correlate clearly in the peripheral areas. The irregular reconstruction at the interface between the original cartilage and the construct might be a reason. A limitation of this study is the low number of cases due to ethical limitations in an animal project. This may be a reason for the lack of significant statements in group U and group S+BMCC. Further studies with a higher case load are required. Another limitation of this study is the manual measuring which can possibly lead to overlapping of the central and peripheral measurements or of the peripheral cylinder and the flanking cartilage. However, we have to mention that the diameter of the probe is only 1 mm. Thus, a very accurate positioning is possible.
For the first time, NIRS was used to evaluate osteochondral constructs in a miniature pig model. In all groups, a correlation between NIRS and the histologic scores could be demonstrated though on different levels. In the central area of the defects a good NIRS measurement correlates with low (good) histologic scores. Further studies are required to evaluate spectroscopy in the tissue engineering of cartilage lesions.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors confirm that this article content has no conflict of interest.
Carl Haasper and Michael Jagodzinski have contributed in equal parts. We thank the team of Medimplant for the support during the animal experiments. We further wish to acknowledge the excellent support of Roland Meister. This study was supported in part by the AO Foundation’s Research Fund (AO 05-H74).